# Formulas from Gasier et al., "Rabinizer: Small deterministic # automata for LTL(F,G)" (ATVA'12) G(a | Fb) FGa | FGb | GFc F(a | b) GF(a | b) G(a | Fa) G(a | b | c) G(a | F(b | c)) Fa | Gb G(a | F(b & c)) FGa | GFb GF(a | b) & GF(b | c) FF(a & G!a) | (GG!a & Fa) GFa & FGb (GFa & FGb) | (FG!a & GF!b) FGa & GFa G(Fa & Fb) Fa & F!a G(b | GFa) & G(c | GF!a) | Gb | Gc G(b | FGa) & G(c | FG!a) | Gb | Gc F(b & FGa) | F(c & FG!a) & Fb & Fc F(b & GFa) | F(c & GF!a) & Fb & Fc GFa -> GFb (GFa -> GFb) & (GFc -> GFd) GF(Fa | GFb | FG(a | b)) FG(Fa | GFb | FG(a | b)) FG(Fa | GFb | FG(a | b) | FGb) # formulas from DBA minimizer XXa GF(a -> XXXb) F(p & XF(q & XF(r & XFs))) F(q & X(p U r)) F(p & X(q & XFr)) p U (q & X(r U s)) G(a -> Fb) & G(c -> Fd) GFa & GFb GFa | GFb | GFc GFa a U b U c U d G(a -> Fb) & Gc (Ga -> Fb) & (G!a -> F!b) p U (q & X(r & F(s & XF(u & XF(v & XFw))))) G(a -> Fb) & G(b -> Fc) G(a -> Fb) & G(!a -> F!b) GFp && GFq && GF r && GF u GF(a <-> XXXb) G(p -> q U r) GF(a <-> XXb) G!c & G(a -> Fb) & G(b -> Fc) G(a -> XXXb) G(a -> Fb) G(a U b U !a U !b) (p U q U r) || (q U r U p) || (r U p U q) # Some random formulas that are determinizable with tba-det X((a M F((!c & !b) | (c & b))) W (G!c U b)) X(((a & b) R (!a U !c)) R b) XXG(Fa U Xb) (!a M !b) W F!c (b & Fa & GFc) R a (a R (b W a)) W G(!a M (c | b)) (Fa W b) R (Fc | !a) X(G(!a M !b) | G(a | G!a)) Fa W Gb Ga | GFb a M G(F!b | X!a) G!a R XFb XF(!a | GFb) G(F!a U !a) U Xa (a | G(a M !b)) W Fc Fa W Xb X(a R ((!b & F!c) M X!a)) XG!a R Fb GFc | (a & Fb) X(a R (Fb R F!b)) G(Xa M Fa) X(Gb | GFa) X(Gc | XG((b & Ga) | (!b & F!a))) Ga R Fb G(a U (b | X((!c & !a) | (a & c)))) XG((G!a & F!b) | (Fa & (a | Gb))) (a U X!a) | XG(!b & XFc) X(G!a | GFa) G(G!a | F!c | G!b) # Some random formulas that should only be determinizable via dstar2tgba # Generated with # randltl -n -1 a b c | # ltlfilt --remove-wm -r -u --size-min=3 --size-max=15 --syntactic-recurrence | # ltlfilt -v --obligation | # ../../src/bin/ltl2tgba -F - -x tba-det -D --stats='%d,%f' | # grep 0, | head -n 30 X(Fc W b) R Fa !b & ((Fa U b) W Xc) G(F!c | (Fb U a)) (c R (b R Fa)) W XGb X((Fb & XFa) R XFc) (Ga R (F!c U b)) W b X(!b | G(b & !a)) R F(c & Fa) G(Fc | Ga | XXF!b) G(F(!a & Fa) U (b U Xc)) G(F!c U X(Xb & F!b)) G(XXFa U (b | a | Fc)) G(c | F!a | (b U Xb)) G(a U X(a | (F!b U Xc))) XF!a R F(b | (!a & F!c)) (c & Xc) R ((!b | XFc) U a) G(Gb | (b & c) | F(!a & XXa)) G(X(Fc & Xa) M Fb) X(!c & Fc) R (c M Fa) G(Ga | X(Fc U (b | X!b))) G(XXFb U (c | (!c & F!a))) ((Fc U b) R Fa) W X!a G(a | X(a R (GFb | (Fc U a)))) (F!c R F!b) W G!a (Fb & !b) R (!a R XFc) F(Fb & c) W Xa G(G!c | ((Fb U a) U c)) (Fa & XXb) R Fc Gc R (F!a & (b U a)) (c R Fa) U X!b GF(b & XXXFc) # Extra ones G(F(a & F(b & Fc))) (GFa & GFb) | (GFc & GFd)