This directory contains benchmark scripts for LTL-to-Büchi translators.
They are all based on lbtt.
==========
CONTENTS
==========
* algorithms
The lbtt configuration of all the algorithms. More about these below.
* small
* big
* known
Run lbtt on, respectively:
small formulae (size 10, 4 propositions)
big formulae (size 12..15, 8 propositions)
known formulae (96 formulae from formulae.ltl)
Each script generates 3 files:
xxxx.cfg: the configuration file for lbtt
xxxx.log: the log of lbtt's execution (also output when the script runs)
xxxx.txt: the summary of the test (also output at the end of the script)
* ltl2baw.in
* ltl2baw.pl
ltl2baw.pl is generated from ltl2baw.in by configure. This perl
script converts the intermediate generalized automata computed by
ltl2ba into a form usable by lbtt.
* formulae.ltl
A list of LTL formulae used by the `known' check.
See ../emptchk/README for the sources.
* parseout.pl
This scripts is used to create *.txt files from *.log files.
====================
ALGORITHMS & TOOLS
====================
The page http://spot.lip6.fr/wiki/LtlTranslationBenchmark explains
all the keys used and the different tools involved in the benchmark.
Spot's configure script checks for the tools needed in the
benchmark, and the script in this directory should omit the tools
that are not available.
=====================
Running the scripts
=====================
1) Install all the third-party translators that you want to check.
They must all be in $PATH and work from there.
Two difficulties comes from Modella and wring2lbtt:
* Modella 1.5.7 produces automata that are not readable by lbtt 1.1.2.
You have to fix the former as follows:
--- modella1.5.7/modella_automa.c 2004-08-30 17:19:47.000000000 +0200
+++ modella1.5.7.fixed/modella_automa.c 2005-04-14 15:07:46.632785000 +0200
@@ -618,6 +618,7 @@ void print_LBA(LBA* b,FILE* output){
if(b->R[j]->source==i){
fprintf(output,"%d ",b->R[j]->dest);
print_form_prefix(b->R[j]->label,output);
+ fputc('\n',output);
}
fprintf(output,"-1 ");
* The automata produced by Wring are translated to the syntax
understood by lbtt using `wring2lbtt' (by the same author of
Modella). wring2lbtt suffers from the same "lbtt syntax"
problem described above, you have to fix this too before it
can be used.
Also wring2lbtt requires a Wring directory in the directory
where it is run; that makes it harder to use as a normal tool
from $PATH. I use the following wrapper in my $PATH to work
around this.
#!/bin/sh
cd ~/src/wring2lbtt && ./wring2lbtt "$@"
This is OK because the filenames supplied by lbtt are absolute.
2) ./configure Spot, and build it.
During the configure process you should see lines such as
checking for lbt... lbt
checking for ltl2ba... ltl2ba
checking for modella... modella
checking for script4lbtt.py... script4lbtt.py
checking for spin... spin
checking for wring2lbtt... wring2lbtt
If some tool is not found, the corresponding tests will be disabled.
You can also use variables such as LBT, LTL2BA, MODELLA, LTL2NBA,
SPIN, and WRING2LBTT to specify the location of any of these scripts
if it is not in $PATH. For instance
./configure LTL2NBA=/home/adl/src/ltlnba/script4lbtt.py
3) Run `make' to build Spot.
4) cd into bench/ltl2tgba/ and execute any of
./small
./big
or ./known
5) Wait...
=======================
Reading the summaries
=======================
The files small.txt, big.txt, and known.txt contain a summary of the
results. Each algorithm is described as two lines formated as
follows.
18: FM, gen, +symb_merge, -exprop, LTLopt
494 / 975 / 100 / 4.25 98798 / 3935920 (100)
The first line presents the name of the algorithm ("FM, gen,
+symb_merge, -exprop, LTLopt") and its number for lbtt (18).
The number is useless. See http://spot.lip6.fr/wiki/LtlTranslationBenchmark
for the naming conventions.
The second line display 7 values:
1. the total number of states of all generated automata (494)
2. the total number of transitions of all generated automata (975)
3. the total number of acceptance conditions of all generated automata (100)
4. the cumulated translation time in seconds (4.25)
5. the total number of states in the synchronized products (98798)
6. the total number of transitions in the synchronized products (3935920)
7. the number of translated automata (100)
Notes:
* Small translation times are not accurate because most of the
translators are run through scripts that translate their input
from and their output to the format understood by lbtt. For fast
translators, most of the time is spent through these wrappers.
(For instance Spot's ltl2tgba is run through lbtt-translate, and
depending on how Spot has been configured w.r.t. to dynamic
libraries, ltl2tgba itself is often a shell script that run the
real binary with the locally built libraries.)
* Some tools will appear to have translated fewer automata than the
others. This normally indicates bugs in the translator. In that
case it is harder to compare the results. (Normalizing the other
values accordingly may not be fair: maybe the translator precisely
failed to translate the largest automata.)
